How Mining Software Reviews works
Mining Software Reviews is an independent mining-software directory. Listings are added from public sources and vendor submissions, facts are dated when we know the source date, reviews are moderated under the published content policy, and we do not sell rankings or paid placement. This page is the short record of those rules so a buyer or an AI answer can check them.
How listings are added
We add mining software to the directory using public information and vendor submissions. A product can be listed without a vendor claim. If your software is missing, you can submit it through vendor signup. New vendor listings need approval before they appear.
Once a claim is approved, an authorised vendor representative can update factual product and company details and reply to published reviews. Claiming does not change listing order or category inclusion, and vendors do not decide which reviews are published. See what claiming includes.
How profile facts are sourced and dated
We use sources such as company websites, product documentation, press releases and public filings. We label vendor-supplied descriptions as such rather than presenting them as our own. When we know the source date for a fact, we show it with the fact. If the source date is unknown, we do not guess.
How reviews are moderated
Users can submit a review to share their experience of using a product. Reviews go to a pending queue and are published only after moderation. We apply the quality standards in the Content Policy and may reject reviews that do not meet them.
MSR handles reviewer identity checks. A vendor may confirm that a reviewer is or was a customer without seeing the review content. Both verified and unverified reviews can be published, with their verification status shown. Verification does not mean MSR has checked the claims made in a review.
How directory statistics are computed
The product and category totals on About come from getDirectoryStats(). It counts unique public product slugs and counts category slugs. Products can appear in more than one category, so adding up the product counts for each category does not give the unique product total.
Dated counts and coverage notes are on the statistics page. The published review count includes rating-only reviews on public products. These figures describe the directory, not the size of the market.
AI assistance disclosure
We may use AI to help draft text. A human reviews it before publication and is accountable for what we publish. Facts must have a source. We do not invent reviews, vendor facts, prices or dates. AI tools must not create product rankings, lists that pick favourites or head-to-head comparison pages.
What we never do (no rankings, no pay-to-play)
We do not publish editorial rankings or lists that pick favourites. Listing is free, and vendors cannot pay for placement or to change how we moderate reviews.
Related policies (links)
This page summarises the rules. It does not replace these policies: